The comments often refer to the text for support but at least half the time there is a mismatch or. Participant, through his or her comments, demonstrates a deep knowledge of the text and the question. Socratic seminar rubric does not meet standard 1 approaching standard 2 meets standard 3 exceeds standard 4 conduct displays little respect for the learning process. Each of the following criteria are worth 10 points. Socratic seminar explanation and scoring rubric relevance the socratic seminar is based on a 2,400yearold philosophy that teaches students to raise probing questions, to think critically about their own ideas and the ideas of others, to support ideas with textual evidence, and to take greater responsibility for their own learning. I know this is a variety on the typical seminar format but it helps to keep the focus on the questions and allows for greater student participation. Sample questions for guided notes are included in the question files, socratic seminar questions on persuasive texts and socratic seminar questions on short stories. You should highlight important information throughout the article. Jamison fort, who teaches 6thgrade social studies at maxson middle school in plainfield, nj, videotaped his students conducting a socratic seminar and the subsequent debrief.
Teaching literature rubrics south korea language arts prompts middle school pdf how to apply names. Socratic seminar pdf my favorite rubric and guide the purpose of a socratic seminar is to achieve a deeper understanding about the ideas and values in a text. Socratic seminars are a teaching tool that empowers students and can turn up the thought level around any topic. The student makes a few comments during the seminar 23. Here are the steps for planning a socratic seminar. The comments express a mixture of original thinkingextensions and repeating others.
Socratic seminar template and samples generic template a. Student evaluation for the socratic seminar saint marys. Then theres the secondary list of things youre going to do when you. Total points 20 points possible in each section 100 number of comments how often did you speak. Criteria you might use to evaluate a socratic seminar activity include engagement everyone listening and sharing, respect no interruptions or putdowns, meaningmaking students understand the text more deeply at the end. A rubric for evaluating a socratic seminar discussion is provided in the assessment section. Rubric for teachers to use to assess socratic seminar participation. A major goal of this class is to develop the students skill to analyze a text, then demonstrate that analysis through speaking. This howto article about socratic seminaring is adapted from a chapter in sarah tantillos 2012 book the literacy cookbook.
Socratic seminars grading rubric a major goal of this class is to develop the students skill to analyze a text, then demonstrate that analysis through speaking and writing. Here are some useful books on socratic teaching that we recommend. Socratic seminars made easy the literacy cookbook blog. Because the seminar involves preparation, it is important that you select a text that students have either just finished reading or are in the process of reading.
You will engage in one as an assessment over postmodernism and the information age. In a socratic seminar, participants seek deeper understanding of complex ideas in the text through rigorously thoughtful dialogue, rather than by memorizing bits of information. Students are required to support every statement with sound reasoning and appropriate examples. Use a detailed rubric to score each of the discussants.
The socratic seminar is a formal discussion, based on a text, in which the leader asks openended questions. The seminar is designed to enable students to explore a text, a problem, an experience. A socratic seminar is method to try to understand information by creating a dialectic in class in regards to a specific text. Offers some analysis, but needs prompting from others. Participants seek deeper understanding of complex ideas through rigorous thoughtful dialogue, rather than by memorizing bits of information. Paragraphs and lines or portions of a score or painting need to be easily identified and referenced. Socratic seminar rubric socratic seminar assessment rubric worksheet. Socratic seminar template and samples social studieshumanities sample a socratic seminar named after socrates is a deep discourse led by questioning. Provides solid analysis, without prompting, to move the conversation forward. This process encourages divergent thinking rather than. Introduce digital breakouts with your students with this interactive free activity. Ppt socratic seminar powerpoint presentation free to. Socratic seminar rubric by teacher stuff and a little. Here are the general guidelines for participating in a socratic seminar and a rubric that will be used to assess your participation.
Sarah has generously given our readers free access to the socratic seminar materials at her site via the links below. Show the students the rubric what about students that dont speak as much. Development of math reasoning collaboratively by ryan higgins, ph. Socratic seminar rubric for individual participants name. This process encourages divergent thinking rather than convergent. Student evaluation for the socratic seminar this rubric is part of the living in christ series. A case study illustrates how socratic seminar is applied in a classroom and how students engage with the process. Demonstrates exceptionally logical and organized thinking. This book is a good general introduction to socratic teaching with a survey of both ideas and practices socratic circles by matt copeland. Another option is to assign to each of the outer circle students one person to assess a rubric score on while they also take notes on the responses. Im a 10th grade teacher at the high school for arts, imagination, and inquiry, and i like to use the socratic seminar to help students understand how they can develop claims and counterclaims, and address these in spoken argument. Socratic circles seeks to give the student the opportunity to demonstrate his her level of understanding of a text and the.
The purpose of a socratic seminar is to achieve a deeper understanding about the ideas and values in a text. Planning for a socratic seminar pre seminar activities. Read and prepare your text before the seminar using the critical reading process. Bring notes and bookmarked pages that are relevant to the discussion. This is a great strategy to keep students engaged in the discussion when they are not actively participating.
Socratic seminar rubric text preparationreading and annotation of text engagementparticipation in discussion and ontask use of textsupport of ideas with text. In a socratic seminar, participants seek deeper understanding complex ideas in the text through rigorously thoughtful dialogue. Provides relevant and insightful comments, makes new connections. Teachers pay teachers is an online marketplace where teachers buy and sell original educational materials. A socratic seminar named after socrates is a deep discourse led by questioning. In the seminar, participants systematically question and examine issues and principles related to a particular content, and articulate different pointsofview.
Theres the list of things that actually have to get done. The easy way to do socratic seminars in your classroom. Socratic seminar guidelines before the socratic seminar read and prepare your text before the seminar using the critical reading process. This rubric may also prove useful to students who are evaluating other students or reflecting on their own participation. Choose a text related to content or an issue to be discussed in the seminar. Socratic seminar rubric exemplary proficient partially proficient developing comments analysis and reasoning clearly references text to support reasoning. Socratic seminar discussion questions a good socratic question is open ended, encouraging discussion rather than regurgitation of facts.
This rubric can be used by teacher or by students to grade a partner. You read and annotate the article that we will be discussing. You will prepare your thoughts on several different questions. Lynda tredaway describes the socratic seminar as a form of structured discourse about ideas and moral dilemmas. Students are expected to articulate their own thoughts as well as listen and respond to others in the the group. Rubric for deeper thinking about learning deeper learning. Students engaging in socratic seminar generally sit in a circle. Pdf files can be viewed on a wide variety of platforms both as a browser plugin or a standalone application with adobes free acrobat reader program. Socratic seminar grading rubric nogales unified district. The socratic seminar is one of the best teaching techniques for engaging students in critical thinking and meaningful discussion of a text. You will lose points if you are talking while others are trying to score points. A practical guide to effective reading, writing, speaking, and listening instructionjosseybass. This books is useful in particular for teachers who teach classes of more than twenty students thinkers guide to the art of socratic. As the opening quote suggests, a seminar is meant to be a different kind of class or instructional strategy.
Slavery and thomas jeffersons legacy please see assessment section in the lesson plan. Within the context of the discussion, students listen closely to the comments of others, thinking critically for themselves, and articulate their own. Teachers may use it to evaluate students on their participation in a socratic seminar. A socratic seminar is a method used to understand information by creating dialectic in class regarding a. Of her ten children, only two are livingjulia, her first born, and wife of charles barnett, who live on an adjoining farm, and. Teaching english literature using a socratic seminar. Choose the text a socratic seminar is grounded in the discussion of a text. In a seminar, participants question and examine issues and ideas related to a text, and articulate different pointsofview about these issues. Demonstrates thoughtful consideration of the topic. Socratic seminar focuses on deep discussion around a central text, so it is important that complex. General characteristics of socratic seminar are discussed at the end of the article. This lesson will provide three rubrics for assessing seminar participation. Socratic seminar in the context of a high school type 2 diabetes curriculum that explores gene and environment interactions.
321 1352 735 1506 397 89 868 967 844 437 586 130 513 1397 11 559 739 664 1229 1211 1445 792 777 207 1425 1022 1252 794 845 570